Researchers Pressured Twitter To Treat COVID-19 Facts as ‘Misinformation’

Must read

Saudi National Bank to lose $1.2B on Credit Suisse rescue

Saudi National Bank chairman Ammar Al Khudairy’s comments last week may end up being one of the most expensive answers delivered on television. ...

Credit Suisse failure follows years of scandal and mistrust—with an Ohio mattress company playing a role

Credit Suisse Group AG, once one of the stalwarts of the global financial system, is no more.  After tense talks over...

UBS on Credit Suisse takeover: ‘We will be de-risking a lot of the tricky businesses that we are inheriting’

UBS Group AG Chairman Colm Kelleher said he will manage down Credit Suisse Group AG’s investment bank, curtailing a source of losses in recent...

New York Community Bancorp looks to acquire failed Signature Bank

New York Community Bancorp is pursuing a deal to acquire failed Signature Bank, according to people familiar with the matter.  The...

Misinformation

The latest Twitter Files shows a partnership between Stanford University researchers and government-funded organizations encouraged social media companies to police true information.

Christian Britschgi |

reason-twitter2

( Cateyeperspective/Dreamstime.com)

Researchers at Stanford University—in partnership with several nonprofits that have received government funding—worked with social media platforms to flag and suppress commentary on COVID vaccines, science, and policy that contradicted public health officials’ stances, even when that commentary was true.

This new information comes from yet another Twitter Files entry of screenshotted emails and reports from independent journalist Matt Taibbi that reveals the back and forth between the Stanford-led Virality Project and receptive Twitter executives about policing alleged COVID misinformation on its platform.

Beginning in February 2021, and continuing with regular reports, Virality Project researchers encouraged Twitter to expand its misinformation policies to include true reports of vaccine side effects, criticism of vaccine passport systems for their imposition on rights and freedoms, and even discussion of legitimate scientific research on breakthrough infections on natural immunity.

Researchers with the project explicitly flagged “true content which might promote vaccine hesitancy,” including other countries banning certain vaccines because of their health side effects. While individual true stories about negative vaccine side effects were not treated as misinformation or disinformation, they could be labeled “malinformation” if they exaggerated or misled people, said researchers.

14.VP told Twitter that “true stories that could fuel hesitancy,” including things like “celebrity deaths after vaccine” or the closure of a central NY school due to reports of post-vaccine illness, should be considered “Standard Vaccine Misinformation on Your Platform.” pic.twitter.com/nOyuw2r5cH

— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) March 17, 2023

Stanford researchers, and later Twitter staff themselves, also flagged campaigns against vaccine passports as a worrisome bridge forming between the anti-vaccine community and the wider “right-wing media sphere.”

15. In one email to Twitter, VP addressed what it called the “vaccine passport narrative,” saying “concerns” over such programs “have driven a larger anti-vaccination narrative about the loss of rights and freedoms.”

This was framed as a “misinformation” event. pic.twitter.com/ZdbKE1tFac

— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) March 17, 2023

In April 2022, the Virality Project issued a report calling for the creation of a new government agency housed within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) that focused on misinformation and disinformation.

DHS briefly tried to create that board but then backed down after an intense public backlash to its authoritarian potential.

Virality Project researchers took exception to politicians like Sen. Rand Paul (R–Ky.) and Rep. Thomas Massie (R–Ky.) relying on research published by the Cleveland Clinic showing no benefits of vaccination to already infected individuals to make the case for protective natural immunity.

The stated concern was that legitimate scientific research was being used to “sow mistrust in American public health institutions.”

35.A Cleveland Clinic study showed previous infection offered the “same immunity” as the vaccine, but VP said discovery was susbservient to narrative: “Whether or not… scientific consensus is changing, ‘natural immunity’ is a key narrative… among anti-vaccine activists.” pic.twitter.com/wmdiynJG4y

— Matt Taibbi (@mtaibbi) March 17, 2023

Some of the Virality Project’s partner organizations received funding from the Department of Defense and the National Science Foundation. The project also said it had developed “strong ties” with federal government agencies.

There’s been a lot of reporting already (including from Reason) on the efforts by government agencies to pressure social media companies to police COVID speech they deemed false or misleading.

The latest Twitter Files shows that the definition of what’s considered damaging misinformation is being stretched to include true things that might cause the public to react in ways that don’t meet the approval of public health officials.

More articles

Latest article

Saudi National Bank to lose $1.2B on Credit Suisse rescue

Saudi National Bank chairman Ammar Al Khudairy’s comments last week may end up being one of the most expensive answers delivered on television. ...

Credit Suisse failure follows years of scandal and mistrust—with an Ohio mattress company playing a role

Credit Suisse Group AG, once one of the stalwarts of the global financial system, is no more.  After tense talks over...

UBS on Credit Suisse takeover: ‘We will be de-risking a lot of the tricky businesses that we are inheriting’

UBS Group AG Chairman Colm Kelleher said he will manage down Credit Suisse Group AG’s investment bank, curtailing a source of losses in recent...

New York Community Bancorp looks to acquire failed Signature Bank

New York Community Bancorp is pursuing a deal to acquire failed Signature Bank, according to people familiar with the matter.  The...

Credit Suisse’s $17B of risky bonds now worthless after takeover by UBS: ‘Those bonds were created for moments like this’

Holders of Credit Suisse Group AG bonds suffered a historic loss when a takeover by UBS Group AG wiped out about 16 billion Swiss...