“Victorian-Era Orgasms and the Crisis of Peer Review”

Must read

Report: Sinema Wants Changes To $740 Billion Tax Hike/Global Warming Bill, Says She’s ‘Taking Her Time’

Senator Kyrsten Sinema is playing coy on whether or not she’ll support the Democrats’ so-called ‘Inflation Reduction Act’...

What Did We Do About Inflation Before Economists?

By John Tamny for RealClearMarkets In their new book America In Perspective, David Sokol and Adam Brandon...

Biden Press Sec. Falsely Claims Supreme Court Ruling on Abortion Was ‘Unconstitutional’ – Prompting Mockery

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre raised eyebrows by declaring the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade...

Manchin-Schumer Energy Deal Proves the Power of The Swamp

By Robert Bryce for RealClearEnergy Never doubt the power of The Swamp. That’s the apparent lesson...

But quite a compelling article in The Atlantic (Robinson Meyer & Ashley Fetters), with the subtitle “A favorite anecdote about the origins of the vibrator is probably a myth.” An excerpt:

It’s among the most delectably scandalous stories in the history of medicine: At the height of the Victorian era, doctors regularly treated their female patients by stimulating them to orgasm. This mass treatment—a cure for the now-defunct medical condition of “hysteria”—was made possible by a new technology: the vibrator. Vibrators allowed physicians to massage women’s clitorises quickly and efficiently, without exhausting their hands and wrists.

It’s a disturbing insight, implying that vibrators succeeded not because they advanced female pleasure, but because they saved labor for male physicians. And in the past few years, it has careened around popular culture. It’s given rise to a Tony-nominated playa rom-com starring Maggie Gyllenhaal, and even a line of branded vibrators. Samantha Bee did a skit about it in March. A seemingly endless march of quirky news stories has instructed readers in its surprising but true quality, including in ViceMother Jones, and Psychology Today.

In short, the tale has become a commonplace one in how people think about Victorian sex. And according to a contentious new paper, it may also be almost totally false.

There is absolutely no evidence that Victorian doctors used vibrators to stimulate orgasm in women as a medical technique, asserts the paper, written by two historians at Georgia Tech. “Manual massage of female genitals,” they write, “was never a routine medical treatment for hysteria.”

“There’s no evidence for it,” says Hallie Lieberman, an author of both the new paper and Buzz, a popular history of sex toys. “It’s inaccurate.”

More articles

Latest article

Report: Sinema Wants Changes To $740 Billion Tax Hike/Global Warming Bill, Says She’s ‘Taking Her Time’

Senator Kyrsten Sinema is playing coy on whether or not she’ll support the Democrats’ so-called ‘Inflation Reduction Act’...

What Did We Do About Inflation Before Economists?

By John Tamny for RealClearMarkets In their new book America In Perspective, David Sokol and Adam Brandon...

Biden Press Sec. Falsely Claims Supreme Court Ruling on Abortion Was ‘Unconstitutional’ – Prompting Mockery

White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre raised eyebrows by declaring the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade...

Manchin-Schumer Energy Deal Proves the Power of The Swamp

By Robert Bryce for RealClearEnergy Never doubt the power of The Swamp. That’s the apparent lesson...

Brits advised to spend less time in the shower

Brits should reduce their showering time by at least 60 seconds to avoid water shortages, The Sunday Times reported, citing sources at companies dealing...